A Yorkshire Tragedy: The Rise and Fall of a Sporting Powerhouse

Miranda Wild writes:

The evening was openly structured as a conversation between the author, Anthony Clavane, and Tony Collins, Professor of Sports History at De MontFort University. 

Anthony Clavane

The pair are introduced as ‘two leading people in the world of sports and culture’ which generates appropriate nods of agreement from the full and vocal crowd. Anthony explains that he was inspired to write this, his third book as he is simply ‘obsessed with sport’ and felt that the best way to mourn his leaving Leeds and his youthful ‘Yorkshireness’ was to write in commemoration. A Yorkshire Tragedy is revealed as the final part of his trilogy of books lamenting the loss of the Golden Age of Sport, which took with it the values of ‘community, identity and belonging’, the themes which the books are centred around.

Anthony begins by fondly linking his connection to the Jewish Community and his love of sport, stating that Don Revie and Anthony's rabbi once agreed that they 'shared a congregation' at different times of the day. The sense of community, Anthony suggests, is missing from the game now and he links this to the decline in Leeds United’s success whilst the city expands. The question of the true cause of the decline is indeed the investigatory purpose of the book - so there will be no spoilers in this blog! Deindustrialisation is however one key factor in the decline as Anthony believes that ‘the economy... definitely affected sport’ due to the personal trinity of home, work and leisure, which receives nods of agreement from a captivated crowd. The book is revealed as concentrating and commentating on the previous rise and current fall of parts of Yorkshire and the connection of this process to sport -  which feels particularly poignant in the Headingley location.

Tony Collins - interviewer

When the floor is opened, the passion Anthony’s discussion has excited in his audience becomes clear as nearly every member’s hand is raised. There are questions and Anthony’s replies detailing the importance of a club’s self-belief, causing introspective analysis on the author’s part as he is a self-confessed ‘glass half-full sceptic’. Optimism then permeates the discussion as Leicester is described as ‘doing a Leeds’ proving that there is still much hope in the sporting arena for smaller, and 'our own', local club. Anthony emphasises the importance of sporting heritage and urges the audience to use it as a way back - further emphasising his earlier interest in the community. This is furthered in Anthony’s closing statement which is also the main point of his book, that ‘sport as a whole is not as egalitarian as it used to be’ and that money is potentially ruining it. This Q and A creates further opportunities for questions in the audience which becomes so stimulated by the discussion that they remain in their seats long after it is officially over to expand on Anthony’s intriguing and passionate views.

Sally Bavage adds:

Thanks to Miranda Wild, from Leeds University, who also helped us to set up the event in Headingley Library.

Audience comments

Very engaging presentation, good discussion and audience participation. They made an unfamiliar subject (to me) fascinating.

I thought it was a very interesting talk and eye opening to hear locals' perspective on the things Anthony discussed.

Interesting discussion on mainly soccer and rugby league directions. Wide varied opinions aired. General opinion is that finance is the god.

Good speaker. Local flavour. Good involvement of audience. Good venue. Thank you.

Brilliant! Very illuminating discussion of social and economic implications of sporting decline. More please!

Excellent! Wide-ranging, and insightful discussion.

Great connections drawn between success and decline in local culture and sport and the same in wider society in Yorkshire.

Excellent event - sport and books personally of great interest!

Brilliant - more of this!

Very enjoyable. Both speakers v. knowledgeable.

Great - good format.

Great event, poorly presented.

Great!

Excellent

-->

A very interesting discussion about sport with Anthony Clavane, I am very interested in sport, particularly rugby league and a lot of the things that we spoke about were quite true.

Films at HEART: The Grump

 Tamsin Scott writes:

When thinking of words to describe a film, 'frustrating' is often one that comes to mind. Charming, too, but not usually to describe the same film. However, these are the two words that sprung to the forefront of my mind within the first ten minutes of The Grump and stuck there throughout its entirety. The main storyline of The Grump attempting to fit in with modern day society after a draining accident had me cringing at every turn, from his racist comments to his ill fated advice. 

Antti Litja as Mielensäpahoittaja

The juxtaposition between the modern woman ‘The Missus’ to the virtually prehistoric title character didn’t seem over-dramatic, as I’m sure everyone knows what it’s like to have a family member that you stare at, slack jawed and wide eyed when they come out with something completely inappropriate. However, you couldn’t help but be charmed by his interactions with his granddaughters, and the way he took care of his paralysed wife showed a more sensitive side to the ageing farmer. 

The flashbacks made me feel nostalgic for a life I never led, and the colour palette of the entire film made it a joy to watch. The ending, however predictable, was a lovely reminder that no matter what differences families have, they can always be solved by baking some sweet buns. If nothing else, this film reminded me to give my Grandad a call.

Sally Bavage writes:
The Cinage 'short' that preceded the Finnish main film was entitled 'Stormy Weather' and was a poignant look at the dying of the light for one of a pair of sisters.  Simply done and very affecting. Cinage is such a good local opportunity for our community to take part in the actualité and the verité of film-making. 

Audience Comments

The film, as usual, was interesting, unusual, intriguing

Another great evening with Films@Heart.  I enjoyed the short and the main feature was excellent

Quite a mixture of human relationships – father and son/husband and wife – and the reaction of a very old man to modern life.  Amusing, farcical and touching – varied background of both urban, glitzy Helsinki ad very rural Finnish farmland

Well acted.  Was a very suitable viewing for anyone who had done the Cinage course.  On that we saw several films about ageing.  Interesting to see views of Finland

Excellent film

Interesting film

Todella upea! (Ed. 'Really cool!' in Finnish)

It's a really nice selection we could see.  It gave me a lot of inspiration and opened the broad view about generation and ageing.  Thank you

Very good.  Interesting story about an old man.  It took me a while to get into the film but eventually it became quite funny.

I like Scandi humour.  Quirky and thought it looked good.  Very moving - funny bits, sad bits, quirky bits, thoughtful.  Thanks.

Really enjoyed it

Most enjoyable – some humour in parts – by Finnish standards laugh-a-minute

Interesting and thought-provoking.  An antidote to Hollywood

Fine

Excellent film

-->